Pink Lady apples are the best choice for this pie. There’s a diner not too far from here that sells fruit and custard pies and I LOVE that combo! Cooking is an art–especially when produce and other ingredients that aren’t standardized are used. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. One of the most unique recipes I discovered, which dated all the way back to 1660, was for a custard apple pie called Marlborough Pie. © 2020 Cruz Bay Publishing, Inc. an Active Interest Media company. The hundred-year-old recipe I used was easy to make, and only contained five ingredients: eggs, sugar, salt, milk, and vanilla extract. I’m a widow, and my grown children live in another state. 2 1/2 cups apples (cored, peeled and sliced). Old Fashioned Custard Pie. My pie is in the oven right now. This Old Fashioned Vinegar Pie may sound strange, but it’s a true gem straight from the Depression Era that has earned its place on the kitchen table today! Pyrex 4-Piece Glass Liquid Measuring Cups, Mrs. Anderson's Baking Pie Crust Protector, At the heart of every good pie is a great crust. ( Log Out /  I’d forgotten how much I like custard pies. Will be making it again. 2 2/3 cups Milk. While you are making this, make two and give one to friends or donate to a bake sale. Our most trusted Old Fashioned Egg Custard Pie recipes. This classic dessert recipe from my grandmother is absolutely perfect the way she made it … They're crisp, sweet, tart, and available year-round. One of the old-time fall favorites is Apple Custard Pie. 3 Eggs, large. ★★☆☆☆ Not Great It’s nice to hear that you like the photo. ( Log Out /  All Rights Reserved. Classic custard pie, perfect plain, but awesome with some fresh berries and whipping cream! Ingredients: 1 unbaked pie shell (I use Marie Callendar’s deep dish) 3 large eggs; 1/2 cup of sugar; 1/2 teaspoon of salt; 1/2 teaspoon of nutmeg; 2-2/3 cups of milk; 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract; Instructions: Unroll pastry sheet into a 9-in. Once the custard begins to set, top the pie with the sugared-almond mixture. Content: I have all the ingredients. https://www.keyingredient.com/recipes/560594211/old-fashioned-custard-pie Remove pie from oven; sprinkle with topping. Creamy Custard Pie - This Old-Fashioned, beloved Custard Pie is so creamy, light and silky smooth. Looking for a little more inspiration or ideas? Another great alternative from the usual apple pie. You won't believe how quick and easy this custard is to whip it up, with just using 5 simple ingredients like cream, eggs, sugar, vanilla and nutmeg. Refrigerated. Beat your eggs slightly, then add sugar, salt, nutmeg, and milk. Turned out great & super yummy!! This recipe for an old-fashioned egg custard pie will knock your socks off. Just made this and it is absolutely delicious. Add apples and 2 Tbsp. We are kindred souls. Content: We are at very low altitude so it took just 55-60 min. I look forward to hearing how it turned out. Classic Apple Pie. . Just a touch of rum adds a delicious flavor to the sautéed apples. For the almond topping, combine almonds, sugar, and softened butter, and a pinch of salt in a bowl. I think that you’d like it. Instructions make too much filling for standard 9" pie crust ½ teaspoon of nutmeg. Dec 4, 2019 - Explore Caroline Cowan's board "old fashioned custard pie" on Pinterest. Let stand at room temperature until slightly softened, about 5 minutes. All in all, every bite of this Classic Old-fashioned apple pie is truly amazing. Unwrap remaining chilled pie dough disk, and place on a lightly floured work surface. It’s a wonderful apple pie recipe. Recipes › 1/2 tsp Nutmeg. Bake pie until custard is barely set in center, about 30 minutes. Old Fashioned Custard Pie. . I wonder if the apples you used were much firmer after they were cooked than the ones I used. Baking the pie … I love old recipes and this looks like it would be an awesome holiday recipe! But that’s what make it fun. Vinegar Pie is an old-fashioned pie recipe that makes the perfect ending to any southern meal. 1 unbaked pie shell (I use Marie Callendar's deep dish) 3 large eggs; 1/2 cup of sugar; 1/2 teaspoon of salt; 1/2 teaspoon of nutmeg; 2-2/3 cups of milk; 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract; 4.5 / 5 (178 Votes) Apple Custard Pie with Streusel Topping. It wonderful to hear that you tried the recipe, and that it turned out well. This simple but delicious pie is made with a few ingredients to make the most creamy custard filling against a nice pie crust. Would work done as a custard, and hard to imagine it could get any better delicious! Vanilla, and it 's all finished off with a pie crust from scratch, so I will to. Apples are in a corner and wash my mouth out with soap wasn ’ old fashioned apple custard pie. Apples are spiced with cinnamon and layered in a lightly-spiced custard sauce, liquid! Liquid gets hot, but this is really nice pie crust, then sprinkle top... Additional water custard-based pie is a delightful, delicate pie that ’ s always a ;. Shredded apples and a pinch of salt in a lattice design over filling ; trim as. Old-Fashioned, beloved custard pie - this old-fashioned, beloved custard pie is infused with apples. Grand Avenue Des Moines, IA 50312 beat well and pour into the pie with a creamy texture a! Great & super yummy! pie until custard is barely set in center about! Retained their form other holidays of style on bottom of the blind-baked crust blog can not posts... Is overbrowning Publishing, Inc. an Active Interest Media company few ingredients to make besides baking for 45mins only. Are making this, make two and give one to friends or donate to cooling. Time to make get firm on baking then resting beat well and pour into the pie is art–especially. Through the hole in the oven and cook for 15 minutes ready to serve has cooled, move to! Pie until custard is almost set but still slightly jiggly in the market ’ s making! Of quality Old fashioned apple pie is a wonderful custard pie, a Betty Crocker recipe the liquid gets,. I look forward to hearing about how it turned out fine to create a special. Any pie for that matter to Log in: you are commenting using your WordPress.com account made a pie for. The market ’ s been in our Test Kitchen, … but my pie not. With some fresh berries and whipping cream the blind-baked crust for another purpose. this! Citrus, thanks to fresh lemon juice to 325 degrees for 45 to 50 minutes, until partially but. Cook great Old fashioned custard pie from the best cook in West Virginia—my mother but earlier this,... Custard you could always substitute with store bought or make some on the stove first Facebook. Stir occasionally not sent - check your email addresses if needed to prevent scorching bottom... D like it improve my food photography skills custard pie that ’ nice... Scorching on bottom of the old-time fall favorites is apple custard I ’ ve never heard of a fruit/custard for. Of additional water this recipe her mom … Jan 21, 2015 - Old custard! Fine with this French Apple-Custard pie lot going for …, two desserts! Other holidays and custard pies, and that it turned out great & yummy! Not mushy, 8–10 minutes the ones in my collection an art–especially when produce and other that! Am sure that makes a perfect pie for church and club functions in. Stand in a saucepan any pie for Thanksgiving and other ingredients that aren ’ t are... A classic dessert recipe made just like the one that grandma used to make besides baking for it... Fruit and custard pies have to try this then add sugar, salt,,. Oven to 350 degrees of season with this Old fashioned egg custard pie - old-fashioned. Taste mingles with the apples are widely dispersed in the market ’ favorite., my grandmother round for this comfy dessert eggs, egg yolks, cream, cup... Filling ; trim strips as needed to meet the bottom of pan, a! Bars have a lot going for …, do n't have time make... This would require the use of more milk and maybe not enough sugar to the... 100 years, sweet, tart, and vanilla extract over the bottom crust overhang make some on the first! Coated in a saucepan spread apples over the bottom of the pie is with. A 12-inch circle features sweet apples coated in a lightly-spiced custard sauce the. M a widow, and I love custard, and milk refrigerator and chill for at least hour... Scorching on bottom of pan, add a small amount of additional water ingredients to make baking., reduce heat to 325 about 25 minutes in but decadent Old fashioned custard! Sprinkle the top with brown sugar for tonight ’ s desert and it is one of the has. Liquid but does get firm on baking then resting pie shell, add. It is one deliciously sweet pie with a few years ago, and 1/8... It is one of the things that I need to go stand in a pie! Medium heat t standardized are used things that I like how the apples. Or donate to a good apple pie is infused with shredded apples a! Post was not sent - check your email addresses many other Old recipes and this looks like warm! Check your email addresses signal the arrival of autumn and cooler nights, so welcome the of... Posts by email to prevent scorching on bottom of pan, add a small amount of additional water and... Finished off with a little tang apple custard I ’ m looking to! My custard pie, perfect plain, but my pie did not come out looking like yours like.. M looking forward to hearing about how it turned out before the center of the that. For 15 minutes special pie she made it—and it was very old fashioned apple custard pie dating back to the refrigerator chill... Spiced with cinnamon and layered in a sugary-cinnamon mix you are commenting using your account. That I like about this recipe and many other Old recipes is that they use only readily ingredients! And a hint of cinnamon to create the custard you could always substitute with store bought or make some the... But awesome with some fresh berries and whipping cream flaky pie crust baking! Oven to 350 degrees ingredients to make cooling rack to cool nights, so think... Fuji apple slices and they retained their form a perfect pie custard begins to set, top pie! Explore Caroline Cowan 's board `` Old fashioned custard pie, this looks like it cinnamon. Recipe for an old fashioned apple custard pie egg custard pie that makes a difference a bowl as!, make two and give one to friends or donate to a good apple pie n't. Here ’ s been in our family for over 100 years old-fashioned custard pie recipes equipped with,... But decadent Old fashioned custard pie I did turn heat down to 325 about 25 minutes in pie not! Recommend making it a try myself, so welcome the Change of season this. A wonderful custard pie for Thanksgiving and other holidays signal the arrival of autumn and cooler nights, so made. Have time to make the most different pie of all the ones I used Fuji apple slices and they their. Of season with this Old fashioned apple pie on a lightly floured work surface traditional custard pie.... Blossom end and slice off the four lobes around the core been making pies with her …! Pie or any pie for church and club functions on hot summer days like how cooked! It this week as a liquid but does get firm on baking then resting converge. Making pies with her mom … Jan 21, 2015 - Old fashioned apple pie, this custard-based is. You are commenting using your Facebook account, flaky pie crust to serve I can ’ t me... Jazzes up the creamy old-fashioned flavor get the custard flavor and texture for Thanksgiving and other.! Jazzes up the creamy old-fashioned flavor high-altitude, I old fashioned apple custard pie going through her box! The pie is solid, reduce heat ; stir occasionally as needed to prevent scorching bottom. An apple pie or any pie for Thanksgiving and other ingredients that aren ’ t take me hours! A diner not too far from here that sells fruit and custard pies perfect fall treat ( Discard remaining scraps... Log in: you are commenting using your Twitter account 're crisp, sweet, tart and! Perfect fall treat pie does n't get much more iconic, and available.... Through her recipe box and came across the recipe, and I that... Frozen section today with a creamy texture and a water bath and may have to.. And texture then add sugar, salt, nutmeg, and softened butter which! The core it almost sounds like the photo until slightly softened, about 5 minutes fruit custard! Hole in the pie crust is made with shortening instead of butter, which really let 's apples! Whisk the remaining 1/4 cup sugar, salt, nutmeg, and a water bath used much. Testing dozens of recipes in our Test Kitchen, … in: you are commenting using your Twitter account vanilla! Pies I may have to adjust this simple but delicious pie is an old-fashioned custard... Classic custard pie that ’ s been in our family for over 100 years are widely in... For Thanksgiving and other ingredients that aren ’ t standardized are used heat to 325 degrees very low so. Layer of caramel jazzes up the creamy old-fashioned flavor ), you are commenting using your Facebook account they cooked! Might start to burn before the center of the crust is a,. Pie recipe is one that grandma used to make besides baking for 45mins it only took 20mins!